CRTC orders Canadian TV distributors to carry Sun News

The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission has issued an order that all five Canadian national news channels (CBC News Network, RDI, LCN, CTV News Channel and Sun News Network) must be carried by all Canadian television distributors as of March 14, 2014.

The order requires the channels be made available, though not necessarily on the basic service. They will also need to be available on a stand-alone basis (i.e. individually) as of May 20 (or May 19, there’s a discrepancy between the languages).

The decision is a big win for Sun News, which has been arguing that carriage problems are the big reason the channel has not been successful. Now, with an order requiring that every cable company offer the channel to subscribers, and without having to buy other channels, they can’t really make this argument any more.

Sun News is already carried by most Canadian distributors. Telus and MTS are the biggest holdouts. But this decision gives it a bargaining chip during negotiations, which will help it push for a higher wholesale subscription fee.

The decision also requires distributors to put each channel in “the best available discretionary package consistent with its genre and programming, unless the parties agree otherwise.” This is open to interpretation, but if distributors create a popular news package, it must include all five Canadian national news channels.

But the biggest win is that it applies to all licensed distributors (some very small distributors with fewer than 20,000 subscribers are exempt from regulation, so this wouldn’t affect them). Though the decision does not discuss it, this appears to apply to analog cable as well, where Sun News currently has no carriage. Though analog cable is now a minority of subscribers nationally, Sun argued that its channel skews toward older Canadians, who are more likely to be on analog cable.

If this is the case (I’ve asked the CRTC to confirm my interpretation), then it will be annoying for distributors who are trying to move to digital cable. Now they’ll have to find a bandwidth-hogging analog channel for Sun News, and if they don’t already distribute LCN and CTV that way, those channels too.

This isn’t a win on all levels for Sun. It doesn’t give the channel what it had originally asked for — mandatory distribution to all Canadians on basic. It also doesn’t regulate channel placement (Sun News had wanted to require distributors to put its channel next to other news channels on the dial), though it establishes guidelines for “news neighbourhoods”, effectively saying that if distributors redo their lineups to put like services together, it should include all five Canadian national news channels near each other. It suggested that failure to do this could result in an undue preference complaint.

Distributors who don’t have their own national news channels (i.e. everyone but Bell and Quebecor) argued that to give these channels this privilege, there must be more stringent criteria for licensing new channels, otherwise there could be an explosion of such channels as everyone starts out of the gate with guaranteed access rights. The CRTC didn’t set new criteria, but because the order only applies to the five services currently in operation, a new service would need a separate decision to get the same rights.

The CRTC says it will look at what criteria it should set for licensing new national news services during its wide-ranging review of the television regulation model. Until it does (the process is expected to take most of 2014), it will not process new applications for national news channels under the “Category C” framework that the five existing ones are subject to.

The decision also doesn’t completely level the playing field. It does not require that news channels on basic be removed from it. So if your provider has CBC News Network, RDI and CTV News Channel on basic, they’re not required to add LCN and Sun News to it as well. It just needs to make those two available.

Quebecor welcomed the decision in a statement: “Sun News will move forward in 2014 by negotiating new cable and satellite agreements that are in alignment with the new policy framework to ensure that Sun News is treated in a substantially similar fashion to other all news channels.”

16 thoughts on “CRTC orders Canadian TV distributors to carry Sun News

  1. Robert H.

    Good. This past year, I travelled to Winnipeg, Hamilton and Charlottetown. At the hotels that I stayed at, Sun News Network was never available. Some of hotels did not have the CTV News Channel either.

  2. Vahan

    Who is still getting news from television or even hooked up to cable? Seems like such an archaic idea. And I am a middle aged man who thinks this, I wonder what the kids are doing?

    1. Fagstein Post author

      Who is still getting news from television or even hooked up to cable?

      During bigger news events, about 13-14 million Canadians are watching news on television, according to BBM. So about half the country.

        1. Fagstein Post author

          How much of that 13-14 million is cable news?

          I haven’t seen it broken down that way. On average, CBC News Network has 1.4% of the total audience share, followed by CNN at 0.9%, CTV News Channel at 0.8% and Sun News at 0.1%. It obviously varies depending on the news of the day, but usually a few hundred thousand viewers during prime time.

  3. j2

    I saw this elsewhere and knew you’d have a piece on it. (Thank you sir)

    Did the Canadian equivalent of the argument that Fox News is entertainment and doesn’t have an obligation to report truth happen here? (Oh, My point is I hope if the carriers are required to carry then they should be required to be news and not entertainment.

    (Disclaimer, I’ve never seen Sun, I cut the cord years ago. My retired-in-America parents have Fox on 8 hours a day, and the lack of critical thinking skills is frankly disgusting.)

    1. Fagstein Post author

      Did the Canadian equivalent of the argument that Fox News is entertainment and doesn’t have an obligation to report truth happen here?

      Plenty of individuals argued that Sun is not a news channel. The CRTC didn’t address those complaints directly, but it did address those from distributors that the standards for national news channels were too low (in terms of things like number of bureaus or hours of daily news). The CRTC said it would revisit those standards as part of its overall review of television in the coming year.

    2. George

      ” lack of critical thinking skills” – interesting observation. But after watching CBC and CTV news channels and their lib-left only approach to “critical thinking” (with the likes of Greg Weston particularly coming to mind not to mention that closet liberal Solomon – I have to wonder which approach is worse?

  4. fred

    the CRTC pretty much wussed out again, failing to stand up and say “no more forced channels”. while they are not forcing people to subscribe they making sure we have to pay for it if we buy a news package.

    the whole review next year thing is equally lame, as they will take an extended period to listen to stakeholders and consult the public, then put in place a policy with 3 to 5 years to comply.

    they are the keepers of the old way, pandering to big arrogant companies.

    1. Fagstein Post author

      the whole review next year thing is equally lame, as they will take an extended period to listen to stakeholders and consult the public, then put in place a policy with 3 to 5 years to comply.

      I’ve yet to see a broadcasting policy from the CRTC given a grace period so long. If they’re complex, they’re given a few months. But it’s rarely longer than that.

  5. Steve Banyan

    And speaking of a “news” network… Tonight, CBC National News aired newsworthy programmes, one about puppies and another about royal scandals. Since when is this news? WHY WHY WHY are we paying for this garbage? It’s the same nothing that fills CBC Radio One’s airwaves. And when I say nothing, I mean *nothing* – zero content for the 5 people who are listening, and again, we are paying the bill. Completely. Overhaul. CBC. Please!

    1. steve b

      ps: today, there is NO news on the cbc news network. Can Canadians expect a refund for monies spent for this 24 hour period without them providing content? ctv is live. cnn is live. even foxnews is live. But cbc? More nothing stories on the royals. Someone somewhere has to change the cbc!!!!!

      1. Fagstein Post author

        ps: today, there is NO news on the cbc news network.

        You’re annoyed that CBC News Network didn’t have live news on Christmas Day? If anything important had happened, I’m sure they would have reported it.

  6. Pingback: Did the CRTC require Sun News be added to analog cable? | Fagstein

  7. Pingback: Global News 1 would add, 100 journalists, 8 new local newsrooms including Quebec City | Fagstein

  8. Pingback: Why Sun News Network failed | Fagstein

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *