The journalists of tomorrow

Students of Concordia University's journalism graduate diploma program

Almost a month ago, The Gazette went through a yearly tradition of inviting journalism students into its office and handing out some awards (read: small bursaries) to those who have stood out among their peers.

This evening went on like others have before it, with the students being invited into the office and being served wine and cheese before some people they don’t know introduce other people they don’t know and hand out bursaries named after people they don’t know.

But there was a big difference this year: a new bursary, named after someone else they didn’t know.

Mike King bursary

The new award was the Mike King bursary, setup in honour of the Gazette business reporter who died suddenly in June. This is a story in itself – normally an endowment sufficient to distribute annual awards takes much longer than four months to build up, but an outpour of donations from friends and colleagues (including myself) meant the first $500 bursary went out right away.

Michael Moore, winner of the inaugural Mike King bursary

Yes, his name is Michael Moore. And yes, he’s heard the jokes. His teachers see his name and make some funny comment about how they love his movies.

One of the disadvantages to a name like this is that Moore is entirely ungoogleable. I missed him during the awards night (hence why some eagle-eyed readers will notice that he’s photographed in the daylight outside Concordia’s Hall Building a few days later), and attempts to find him online were entirely fruitless. Thankfully we were still able to get in touch.

Moore is in his third year as a journalism undergrad, with some English courses on the side. His goal when he graduates in the spring? “I would like to get a job.”

Permitted to daydream a bit, he says he’d like to become a sports writer, penning long columns (Dave Stubbs, look out). He sees people like Peter King of Sports Illustrated as role models.

But he knows he’s not going to start out as a high-profile columnist, and he’s ready to start small.

“I’m willing to go to (small towns), like Mike did, if that’s what it takes” he said, noting the career path of the man whose name is attached to his bursary. Mike King worked in Windsor, Ont., Kelowna, B.C. and other small towns in western Canada before getting his dream job at The Gazette.

Lewis Harris award

Lew Harris was a reporter and later a copy editor at the Montreal Star and Gazette until he died of pancreatic cancer in 1999. He had, according to his Gazette obituary, a “quick, dry sense of humour and a hidden flair for whimsy.”

Married to reporter Marian Scott and the brother of copy editor Leon Harris, Lew covered politics and crime in his reporting days, and started up some controversy in the 1984 Canadian election campaign when he noticed Liberal leader John Turner had a bum-patting habit.

The bursary started shortly after Harris died. Its first winner was a Concordia journalism student by the name of Caroline Plante. Plante is now the National Assembly reporter for Global Montreal.

Katherine Lalancette, winner of the Lewis Harris award

Journalism student, fluently bilingual, magazine writer, former Alouettes cheerleader. Guess which of these raised eyebrows when it was brought up during the awards ceremony.

Sure enough, fourth year undergrad Katherine Lalancette once danced with the pom poms for Montreal’s Canadian Football League team. There’s even video evidence online.

But Lalancette was a bit surprised when she heard this tidbit mentioned while her award was presented. The introductions are done mostly based on each student’s application, and Lalancette purposefully didn’t mention her cheerleading on hers.

Not that she wasn’t proud of her past – cheerleading at that level is a lot of work and takes a lot of practice – but she feared that this information might contribute to prejudice against her.

Lalancette has already gotten some real-world media experience under her belt as a contributor to Loulou magazine. Born in Sherbrooke but raised in Montreal, she’s fluently bilingual and writes in both languages – a huge asset in the Montreal media environment.

As for her future, she’s still unsure. “That’s a big question now that I’m graduating,” she says. She might want to apply to Columbia University to continue her studies, or be a feature writer about social issues (a common theme among the award winners tonight), or continuing to write about fashion and beauty.

But she’s not planning to go back to cheerleading anytime soon.

Katherine Lalancette is on Twitter at @kik_tweets

Susan Carson award

Susan Carson was a feature writer and columnist at The Gazette from 1979 until 1988, when she died of complications following brain surgery.

“Carson was a champion of the poor, the abused, the disabled,” The Gazette wrote when the fund was established. “She took their problems to heart and wrote about them; her stories appeared in The Gazette as well as in other Canadian publications.

“Readers responded with jobs for those who needed work, shelter and clothing for people who had lost their homes and opportunity for those who had lost hope. They identified with her loving and gently humorous columns about her family and how she managed to juggle her job with her role as mother and wife. And they were strengthened by the determination of brave, sick children she wrote about, the dignity of mothers on welfare trying to raise families or the resolve of people who refused to allow disabilities to get in the way of productive lives.”

Carson, who was married to John Kalbfleisch (now the Second Draft columnist) wrote a column about life as a working mother.

Mel Lefebvre, winner of the Susan Carson bursary

Mel Lefebvre is definitely an idealist. The Montrealer’s bachelor’s degree is in environmental science, and she just started up a Concordia chapter of Journalists for Human Rights (it’s on Facebook). Her dream job isn’t as a general assignment reporter, but as a communications director for the David Suzuki Foundation. Failing that, she’d be happy with a feature writer job at National Geographic.

“Cheesy, but … yeah,” she admits, acknowledging that neither dream is particularly likely.

Still, her goal is to change the world for the better, and “hopefully journalism is the right tool,” she says.

Mel Lefebvre is on Twitter at @mlynnelefebvre

Philip Fisher bursaries

The most ancient of the Gazette journalism bursaries are named after Philip Fisher, who was president of the Southam newspaper chain from 1945 to 1961. Southam owned The Gazette until the newspaper chain was sold to Hollinger and then Canwest.

Among previous winners are Catherine Solyom and Ann Carroll, both of whom went on to become reporters at The Gazette.

The bursaries are given out annually to two Concordia graduate diploma students.

Carmen Fabio, winner of a Philip Fisher bursary

Carmen Fabio’s previous career was designing graphical interfaces for nuclear power plant simulators.

And she quit that to go into journalism.

The born-and-bred Montrealer wanted a change, she says, and to do something that she enjoyed rather than something that made her rich.

“Do I want money, or do I want to enjoy getting up in the morning?” she asked rhetorically. Deciding that she preferred to change the world, she enrolled in Concordia’s journalism graduate diploma program, where she’s the … umm … dean of the class. And by that I mean she’s surrounded by relative children.

The former design art student says she would like to go into radio documentary. But, like her colleagues, she’ll take what she can get.

Carmen Fabio is on Twitter at @Carma999

Meagan Wohlberg, winner of a Philip Fisher bursary

“I actually care about things,” Meagan Wohlberg says about her desire to change the world.

Wohlberg grew up in northern Saskatchewan and studied philosophy and English in her undergraduate years at the University of Saskatchewan.

“I want my career to mold to my politics,” she says. She wants to give a voice to the voiceless, to help people who are disadvantaged tell their own stories, and she rejects the idea that all stories must be balanced. “I think there are ways of giving a balanced view” without giving equal time to sides that are illegitimate.

She says she’d see herself working for an alternate, online publication, combining social work with journalism.

“I don’t think there’s a person who doesn’t have a voice,” she says.

Meagan Wohlberg is on Twitter at @meaganimous

The losers

Three adorable Fagstein fans gather around my chins for a photo

Though the two undergraduate winners were informed of their bursaries in advance, the entire graduate diploma class was brought in and their wins were surprises.

When I started interviewing the winners, a few of the non-winners got a bit testy with me, wondering why I wasn’t interviewing them. I felt bad. I mean, I didn’t want to exclude anyone, but I didn’t have time to interview dozens of journalism students about their futures.

I especially felt bad when I found out they were fans of this blog. So, hi there. At least you get your photo on my blog.

(Don’t feel too bad, though. When these awards were handed out in 2004, I was one of the students present, and I didn’t win anything either. So some day you might grow up to become a sarcastic blogger too!)

There were guys in this class too.

22 thoughts on “The journalists of tomorrow

    1. Fagstein Post author

      Hey fagstein! Don’t call them losers, it’s not nice. You didn’t win all the time.

      You’re right. In fact, I specifically didn’t win any of these awards when they came up for me. I say “loser” only in jest.

    1. Fagstein Post author

      Windsor is not a small town.

      You’re right. It’s the 20th most populous city in Canada at just over 200,000 inhabitants. But it feels small in my gut. And my gut feeling matters more than facts, doesn’t it?

    1. Faiz

      as one who does not believe in objective journalism, i disagree.

      subjective reporting means understanding that every report has a perspective.

      This can be or corporation or it can be a homeless person, or anything in between.

      i think there is a difference between objectivity and honesty, Fox lacks both.

      1. Jim J.

        subjective reporting means understanding that every report has a perspective.

        …but that’s not what she said, at least according to this blog. What she said was, “she rejects the idea that all stories must be balanced.”

        Since everyone generally recognizes that outlets such as Fox News are pretty much dedicated to producing an unbalanced perspective on the news, her rejection would seem to be a validation of Fox’s approach.

        …or is it only media outlets on the left that are permitted to engage in what you euphemistically call, “subjective reporting?” (Personally, I would call it “advocacy journalism.”)

        1. Fagstein Post author

          Some people would see advocacy journalism as a positive, not a negative, when they’re advocating for a side that doesn’t have any power.

          There’s certainly a lot of nuance here, and in my experience a lot of people who are hard leftists in university journalism schools will end up either outside the field of journalism because it doesn’t do enough to change the world, or will find their positions moderated when they learn that the world isn’t so black and white.

          This particular journalist’s stated goal is to give voices to the voiceless, and to help people who don’t have the means to tell their own stories. Maybe that’s too biased to be considered “journalism”, but it’s a laudable goal, even if I don’t necessarily agree with it fully.

          1. Jim J.

            Maybe that’s too biased to be considered “journalism”

            In my own opinion, I would say that “advocacy journalism” is an oxymoron.

            If you want to give a “voice to the voiceless” (which is like saying you’re in favor of cleaner air, justice for all, more prosperity and cuddly kittens – a bland and feel-good platitude that one finds it hard to find fault with), then you are an advocate. And that’s fine, assuming you enjoy it and can make a living out of it.

            But if you’re going to hold yourself out to be a “journalist” with an agenda, then you aren’t really a “journalist,” at least by the definition that a generally reasonable person would have.

            Advocate. Journalist. Choose one, please.

  1. W G, Gatineau

    Yes, the young idealistic noble defenders of humanity want to be journalizing against the tyranny of the corporate machine that run our north american corporacy but how long before they are writing greenwashing tributes to the alberta tar sands industry like we see regularly in the gazette?

    Honestly, I wish them the best. I just hope they don’t go over to the dark side.

  2. Justine Yu

    Congratulations to all the winners! However big or small those bursaries are, it’s a fantastic achievement to be proud of.

    And a shout to Mel for starting up the jhr School Chapter at Concordia…love from Head Office!

    Best of luck to all the winners and keep on blogging Mr. Fagstein ;)

    Justine Yu
    Social Media Coordinator

  3. David Pinto

    I didn’t think of it before, in spite of Faiz’ comment, but all the grads are women. Are male journalists an endangered species?

    1. Fagstein Post author

      all the grads are women

      All the grads in the first photo are women. There were men there as well. It’s been clear over the past decade or so that there are a lot more women interested in journalism than men. But at the same time, I wouldn’t say male journalists are an “endangered species”. It’s hardly the most sex-biased profession.

  4. Pingback: More journalists of tomorrow – Fagstein

  5. Steve W

    Fagstein, any idea what happened to Global Montreal’s National Assembly reporter Caroline Plante? Caroline is still listed on Global Montreal website(maybe maternity leave?). I’ve asked before to Global Montreal, but could never get a response.

    1. Fagstein Post author

      Fagstein, any idea what happened to Global Montreal’s National Assembly reporter Caroline Plante?

      I believe it is maternity leave. She had a second baby about about a year ago.

      1. Steve W

        Thanks. Any idea what happened to Amanda Jelowicki from maternity leave? She was suppose to return to Global Montreal on-air several months ago. Outside of her one off return to Global Montreal in May on Federal Election Night, she hasn’t returned.

  6. Pingback: Even more journalists of tomorrow | Fagstein

  7. Mel

    Hey – This is Mel – winner of the Susan Carson award mentioned above. I DID work in communications at the David Suzuki Foundation. So, there.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *